The Court of Appeal upholds that an Employee on Probation is Entitled to the Right to be Heard before Termination of employment
Authored by Irene Kashindi, FCIArb, & Faith Wangong’u
Introduction
The Court of Appeal in Red Lands Roses ltd v Mugo (Civil Appeal 68 of 2016) [2025] KECA 96 (KLR) ( herein referred to as the Red Lands Roses case) upheld the decision in Monica Munira Kibuchi & 6 Others v Mount Kenya University; AG (Interested Party) [2021] KEELRC 2310 (KLR) which declared that section 42 (1) of the Employment Act, 2007 (the Act) is inconsistent with Articles 24, 41 and 47 of the Constitution to the extent that it excludes employees on probation from the provisions of section 41 of the Act which guarantees every employee the right to be heard before a decision on termination of employment is made.
Our earlier alert on the Monica Munira case is available here: https://l1nk.dev/3fwn416
The effect of this development is that the procedural requirements of termination of employment apply to employees on probationary terms/contracts as they do to other regular employees.
Before these decisions, employees on probation could simply be dismissed on notice but, this is no longer the case as discussed in detail below.
Facts of the case in the Red Lands Roses Case
The employee was employed by the employer as a human resource manager. The contract of employment was subject to a probation period of 3 months during which either party could terminate the contract by giving one month’s notice. Towards the end of the 3 months, the employer terminated the contract with immediate effect. The reason for termination was that the employer had reviewed the employee’s performance and found that there was a mismatch between the position she held and her professional experience.
The employee filed a claim on 30th October 2012 at the Employment and Labour Relations Court (then known as the Industrial Court), for alleged unlawful, unfair and wrongful termination. She stated that her employment was terminated without a valid reason and that she was denied the right to a hearing before termination. According to her, this was in violation of Articles 27, 40, 41 and 50 of the Constitution and Sections 5, 41, 43, 45 and 49 of the Employment Act, 2007. The employer’s argument was that this being a probationary contract, there was no obligation to conduct a hearing before terminating it. The employer relied on section 42 (1) of the Employment Act which excludes employees on probation from the provisions of Section 41 of the Act. Section 41 of the Employment Act provides for the right of an employee to notification and hearing before termination of employment. The ELRC held that the employer had dismissed the employee unfairly. This was because the employer failed to issue the 30 days’ notice required under the contract and terminated the contract without reviewing the employee’s performance. As such, the reason for termination was not legitimate.
Being dissatisfied with the decision of the Industrial Court, the employer lodged an appeal at the Court of Appeal. One of the issues for determination was whether an employee on probation is entitled to a fair hearing before termination of employment.
The Findings and Decision of the Court of Appeal
It is worth noting that the parties argued the case at the Industrial Court and the Court of Appeal on the premise that section 42 (1) of the Employment Act was still valid. The Court analyzed a broad range of precedents, tracing conflicting jurisprudence within the ELRC on the constitutionality and scope of Section 42 of the Employment Act, 2007. Some of the decisions are highlighted below.
- Carole Nyambura Thiga v Oxfam [2013] & Mercy Karingithi [2014]: Although this case did not strictly relate to the interpretation of section 42 (1) of the Act the Judge hinted that the protections afforded to regular employees are not available to probationary employees.
- Danish Jalang’o v Amicabre [2014] & Dixon Amdama v Amani Tiwi [2015]: Affirmed a strict reading of Section 42
(1) that the procedural and substantive protections are ousted during probation.
- Vitalis Adhere v Longhorn [2015]: Sharply contrasting the above decisions, the Court strictly applied Section 45 of the Employment Act which requires an employer to give valid reasons and follow fair procedure for termination even during probation.
- Evans Kiage Onchwari [2016]: The Court stated in passing, that Section 42 was unconstitutional, citing that the limitation of the employee’s right based on their length of service as in probationary contracts does not meet the threshold for limitation of rights under article 24 of the Constitution.
- Monica Munira Kibuchi & 6 others v Mount Kenya University [2021]: A pivotal judgment by a 3-judge ELRC bench which declared Section 42(1) unconstitutional for violating Articles 41 and 47 of the Constitution to the extent that it takes away procedural safeguards from a probationary employee.
This ruling had not been appealed by the time the Red Lands Roses case was heard by the Court of Appeal and was therefore deemed binding.
Final Appellate Determination
The Court of Appeal held that:
- The core issue was no longer just the Industrial Court’s purported error in the interpretation of Section 42 (1) of the Employment Act as pleaded by the Appellant but the legal status of that Section.
- Given the ELRC’s uncontested declaration of unconstitutionality in Monica Munira case, Section 42(1) was no longer enforceable.
- Accordingly, even if the employer complied with the now-invalid provision, the termination remained unlawful under the Constitution.
- The Court dismissed the appeal, finally holding that it could not enforce a provision that had been declared null and void by a court of competent jurisdiction.
Implications for Employers
Section 42(1) of the Employment Act is effectively null and void. Termination procedures during probation are subject to both procedural and substantive fairness.
Disclaimer: This publication is for general information only. It should not be relied upon as legal advice. The sharing of this information will not establish a client relationship with the recipient unless MMK is or has been formally engaged to provide legal services.
